Jaggery, Honey Or Coconut Sugar: Are These Natural Sweeteners Really Better Than Regular Sugar?

Jaggery, honey, and coconut sugar are marketed as healthier options to white sugar. However, do they have any health benefits? Compare the nutrition facts, impact on blood sugar, and the best option among them.

Natural sweeteners like jaggery, honey and coconut sugar are often said to be healthier options to use in place of white sugar. People now incorporate these natural sweeteners in their home-made desserts or other food items such as coffee and smoothies so that they can cut back on their refined sugar intake. Though the three of them vary in terms of taste, processing and other nutrients, it would be wrong to say they have a positive impact on one’s health.

What Is Natural Is Not Necessarily Healthier

Though white sugar provides calories, it does not provide good amounts of vitamins or minerals. Jaggery, which is derived from concentrated sugarcane juice, can keep some amount of minerals in it such as potassium and iron. Honey holds some amount of antioxidants along with other plant compounds just like coconut sugar.

Still, the amount of these nutrients is very little and does not lead to any significant differential in the given serving sizes. Simply replacing white sugar with these sweeteners does not guarantee that one’s diet has become healthier.

What are the implications for blood glucose levels?

All sweeteners consist of sugars which can elevate blood glucose levels. Honey is predominantly made of glucose and fructose while jaggery has mainly sucrose. Coconut sugar also contains significant amounts of sucrose.

Even though the glycaemic index varies according to the composition and quantity, they shouldn’t be regarded as reliable replacements for blood sugar levels. Diabetics or prediabetics need to pay attention to the number of carbohydrates they eat instead of thinking that natural sweeteners can be consumed freely.

What about weight issues and heart health?

Over-consuming refined sugar adds up to calories and eating extra calories can cause extra weight gain and metabolic problems. Natural sweeteners still add calories and using too much of them, one could counteract his efforts aimed at weight loss.

Regardless of the fact that honey, jaggery and coconut sugar seem less processed and more traditional, the organism still has to process sugars that are contained in them. The quantity you consume is more important than whether the sweetener is advertised as natural or not.

How to Make a More Healthy Choice?

The best method is to lower the degree of sweetness instead of replacing the sugar. Start reducing the sugar in a cup of tea or coffee and in desserts that you make. Fresh fruits are sweet as well; however, they also have vitamins, minerals and fibres, making them a good alternative in various dishes.

Should you use such natural sweeteners as jaggery, honey or coconut sugar for taste, use them sparingly and take them into account in the added sugar calculation.

In short, natural sweeteners can have different tastes and some small nutritional differences; however, they are not always healthier than white sugar. Therefore, the most important is to try and reduce the total amount of sugar in your diet.

-This article is authored by Ms. Chitra BK, Chief of Dietetics, KIMS Hospitals, Electronic City, Bengaluru

Leave a Comment