Mannat Renovation Rules Different From Normal House Crz Heritage
The proposal for renovation of actor Shahrukh Khan’s Mumbai house Mannat and construction of two additional floors has got relief from the Supreme Court. But this does not mean that different laws apply to the house of a famous person than to ordinary people. The basic principle is the same. Construction should be as per law. The difference is that a property like Mannat is near the beach and in the heritage area. Therefore, more approvals and technical checks are required here compared to a normal house. Let us understand, amidst this latest controversy and the initiative of the Supreme Court, whether the rules for renovation/adding a new floor in a property like Shahrukh Khan’s bungalow Mannat are different from a normal house?
Supreme Court lawyer Ashwini Kumar Dubey says, on July 14, 2026, the Supreme Court refused to interfere in the petition in which the approval of Coastal Regulation Zone for Mannat was challenged. The court found that the relevant authorities had examined the proposal and there was adequate compliance with the law in the process. The proposal is limited to adding seventh and eighth floors above the existing building and some renovation.
He told that Mannat’s case did not come into discussion because it is the house of a film actor. Mannat falls in the Coastal Regulation Zone. It is a heritage building. BMC laws also have to be imposed on this. Even in Mumbai, not every house has as many rules as are applicable to Mannat. There is no difference in the rules of a common man’s house and a special man’s house.
Did the Supreme Court give permission to build floors directly?
The Supreme Court did not approve the new building plan. He rejected the challenge, which was against the earlier approval. The result was that there was no immediate legal restriction on approval. Still, the builder will have to follow every condition. This includes approved building plans, structural safety, fire safety, environmental conditions and local body permissions. If the work deviates from the approved plan, officials can take action. Therefore, it would be more correct to say that the way for renovation of Mannat and the proposed two floors is open, but the work can be done only within the approved conditions.
Supreme Court.
What is the difference between a common house and a house like Mannat?
Some rules also apply for renovation of a normal house in Mumbai. Small interior changes, such as painting, furniture, tiles or non-structural work, often fall into a separate category. But if any work changes the wall, beam, column, height, floor area or use of the building, then permission is required. Building an additional floor is a big construction job. In this the load carrying capacity of the building is seen. It is also checked whether the new construction conforms to neighborhood rules, road, parking, open space and fire safety standards. Mannat’s case is more sensitive because it is in the coastal area of Bandra. Coastal environment laws may apply in such areas. In the case of a building having heritage status or heritage impact, the concern of architectural conservation is also added. This is the reason why the file is not limited to the Municipal Corporation only.
Prayer. Photo: PTI
Why are Coastal Regulation Zone rules important?
Coastal Regulation Zone. This system is in place to control construction in India’s coastline, gulf, tidal water areas and sensitive areas around them. The Coastal Regulation Zone rules have been made under the framework of the Environment Protection Act, 1986. Their objective is to protect the coastline, biodiversity, coastal ecology, drainage and public interest.
Not every construction is banned in coastal areas. But the type of construction, location, height, existing structure and impact on the ground are checked. An important point of contention in Mannat’s case was the Coastal Regulation Zone clearance. As per available reports, Maharashtra Coastal Zone Management Authority had given approval for additional floors on January 3, 2025. Later this approval was challenged in the National Green Tribunal. NGT accepted that the approval given in this case was in accordance with the rules.
What is the role of Maharashtra Coastal Zone Management Authority?
Maharashtra Coastal Zone Management Authority is an important state level institution. Its job is to look at the proposed activities in the coastal areas on the basis of the rules of the Coastal Regulation Zone. This institution examines the category of the site, coastal distance, environmental sensitivity and nature of the proposed work. If needed, she can give approval with conditions. Even after approval, it does not mean a free hand. The construction has to be done only as per the conditions of the approval letter. If wrong information is given in a project or conditions are violated, the approval may be questioned. Complaints about violation of environmental rules can reach the competent authority and judicial forums.
BMC.
Then what is the role of BMC?
Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation, or BMC, is the main local body for building construction in Mumbai. Its job is to look at the building plans, grant development permission and monitor the construction. The BMC generally looks at whether the proposal is in compliance with the Maharashtra Regional and Town Planning Act, 1966, applicable development control rules and municipal corporation laws. The Development Control and Incentive Regulations, 2034 are also important in Mumbai. BMC had approved Mannat’s building plan in November 2024. Mere Coastal Regulation Zone clearance is not sufficient without BMC approval. Both processes are different, but related to each other.
Why are heritage rules needed?
Many old buildings, areas and landscapes in Mumbai hold cultural significance. In such cases, heritage conservation rules may apply. The purpose of these rules is to protect the building identity, external appearance, historical value and urban heritage. In heritage investigation, it is seen how much the proposed change will affect the original form. Special attention may be given to exterior design, height, facade, visual impact and protection of old structures. This does not mean that changes can never happen in the heritage complex. Changes are possible, but with permission and conditions. This is why such a property may require more documents and expert opinion than a normal house.
Role of National Green Tribunal and Supreme Court
The National Green Tribunal hears cases related to the environment. Mannat’s case was first challenged before the Western Regional Bench of NGT, Pune. From here the petition was rejected. After that the matter reached the Supreme Court. The Supreme Court refused to interfere in the NGT’s decision. The court also clarified that the decision is not influenced by the fame of any person. Its basis is law, records and investigation by competent authorities.
What is the message for the common citizen?
This case explains a general legal principle. Any person can renovate his house. He may also propose additional floors. But he will have to follow local building rules. Coastal Regulation Zone rules may apply in the coastal area. Separate advice or permission may apply in heritage areas. In multi-storey expansion, structural engineer’s report, approved plans and fire safety compliance may be required. In the case of Mannat, the rules are not different. Rather, due to the location, nature of the building and the proposed construction, investigation has been done at more levels. The meaning of the Supreme Court’s relief is that the approvals were not proved to be illegal on the available records. The validity of the construction will continue to depend on compliance with the agreed conditions.
Also read: How dangerous is paraquat dichloride used in fields for humans?
